The Portfolio Moves That Pay Off When Markets Get Weird

When every headline tells you they don’t know which way the market is going, the challenge isn’t to find better investments; it might be to just wait it out. It may feel like the right thing to do to immediately react to the latest trend reports of a volatile market, but here’s what’s actually worth your attention for how to protect your portfolio.*

Mistaking complexity for progress

A common mistake for investors is assuming that a larger portfolio requires a more complicated strategy. Often, the opposite is true.

You don’t need five new accounts and an elaborate portfolio of speculative stocks. For investors, managing market volatility starts with knowing what you have, not guessing what the market will do.

That looks like asking:

• How much is in long-term retirement accounts?
• How much do I have in cash?
• How much, if any, is in a taxable brokerage account?

The next time you pull up your investment account (like a Roth IRA), look at it a little differently than you used to.

What is a Roth IRA?

A Roth IRA isn’t an investment itself; it’s a tax-advantaged account that holds your investments. Contributions go in after tax, and qualified withdrawals come out tax-free. To qualify for tax-free withdrawals, you generally need to be at least 59 ½ and have held the account for at least five years. Keep in mind that Roth IRA eligibility phases out at higher income levels. 

Instead of asking “did my investments do well?” ask “does the overall allocation still make sense?”

Consider whether you’re holding the right mix across taxable and tax-advantaged accounts, and what a 20% market drop would actually mean for your financial goals. 

A list of investment vehicles and what they’re best for

Depending on where you are personally (financially and in terms of risk tolerance) here are the investment vehicles worth knowing about.

Asset / Vehicle	Best for …
High-Yield Savings Accounts and CDs	The risk-averse portion of your portfolio, high-yield savings accounts and certificates of deposit (CDs) offer safety and a predictable return. They’re FDIC-backed, which means your principal is protected up to federal limits. They won’t outpace a bull market, but they won’t drop either.
Dividend Stocks	Dividend-paying stocks can provide an income stream even in down markets, which helps soften the volatility blow. Rather than relying entirely on share price appreciation, you collect regular payments simply for holding the stock.
Index Funds and ETFs	Index funds and ETFs are a long-term cornerstone for most investors. Diversification is built in, and because they track a broad index rather than individual companies, they remove much of the timing pressure.
REITs (Real Estate Investment Trusts)	REITs give you real estate exposure without the need to own or manage property directly. By law, they’re required to distribute at least 90% of their income as dividends, which can make them attractive for income-focused investors during volatile periods.
Treasury Bonds and I-Bonds	Government-backed securities like Treasury bonds and I-Bonds are a traditional safe harbor. I-Bonds in particular are inflation-adjusted, meaning their yield moves with inflation, which can be valuable when prices are rising and market returns are uncertain.
Gold and Commodities	Gold and commodities have historically acted as a hedge because they can move independently of equities. A small allocation can help reduce overall portfolio volatility without abandoning growth-oriented investments entirely.
Crypto	Unlike stocks, crypto is not subject to the wash-sale rule, meaning you can sell at a loss and immediately buy back the same asset. That said, tax rules around crypto continue to evolve, so it’s worth staying current or consulting a tax professional.

Managing a portfolio is also about managing behavior

When headlines get louder, you don’t need to overhaul your entire portfolio. Focus on what would justify a real change and what is simply market noise. 

Rebalancing your portfolio once holdings drift too far from their intended mix is very different from panic-selling because a bad week feels like a personal injury. The first is a strategy. The second reaction is stress in action. It’s important to understand and know this distinction. 

For new investors, this is one reason portfolio management is emotional as much as it is mathematical. Many investors think the hard part is choosing investments. Often, the harder part is staying the course when the market gives new reasons to doubt your own strategy, sometimes on a daily basis. 

So, if you see your investment account go red, you might feel the urge to move the money back to savings, but before you do this, remember why you set it up in the first place: not to get rich quickly, but to see results over time.

Taxes are part of portfolio management

Once your portfolio starts growing, taxes become part of the picture, not just something to sort out in April. 

Selling at a profit creates a taxable gain. Dividends and interest are taxable, too. But if you have positions that are down, you can sell them to offset those gains. This is known as tax-loss harvesting, and it’s one of the few upsides of a rough market.

It also matters how long you’ve held something before you sell. Hold for more than a year and you pay a lower tax rate. Sell too soon and the bill goes up. For a deeper look, check out: Essential Tax Tips for Maximizing Investment Gains. 

Check out how to enter capital gains and losses directly in TurboTax. 

You don’t have to go at it alone. If you want a second set of eyes, with TurboTax Expert Assist Premium you can connect with a tax expert who understands investments and can review or even fully prepare your return when it’s tax season.

Staying the course

Market volatility feels very personal when investing is new. It may be the first red day, the first alarming headline, or the first moment of wondering whether to sell everything.

A helpful approach is to decide in advance:

• How much of a drop feels tolerable based on goals and time horizon?
• How long is the investing timeline really?
• What will trigger a calm review, rather than a panic decision?

You can’t control the market. What you can control is your system for handling money and the meaning you attach to each swing.

In uncertain times, building wealth is less about being fearless and more about being prepared enough to keep going.

---

*The goal in this article isn’t to tell you what to do; it’s to show you where individual investors commonly look during uncertain markets, explain the tradeoffs, and let you decide what fits your personal situation. This isn’t financial advice; everyone’s financial picture is different, and a certified financial planner (CFP) can help you determine what’s right for you specifically.